Reviews for Tibetan Tales from the Top of the World

Index
Tibetan Tales from the Top of the World Reviews
Midwest Book Review
CLCD
Kirkus Reviews
Shambhala Sun
All Pages


     




Review Highlights      

For full reviews use index


Kirkus Reviews The paintings are bright and their subjects expressive ... a good addition to large folklore collections.
Midwest Book Review
(5 Stars)

Paging through "Tibetan Tales from the Top of the World" it is easy to see why this author/illustrator deserves such high honors and awards.

Children's Literature Comprehensive Database [The stories] reflect the unique blend of thoughtful actions and deeply held values that characterize the Tibetan lifeway...a wonderful gift to young readers.

Shambhala Sun Magazine

Recommended book for the holidays: Tibetan Tales from the Top of the World features three traditional stories in both English and Tibetan...dreamy illustrations...



 

Midwest Book Review (5 Stars), December 2009


Featuring a foreword by the Dalai Lama and preface by Richard Gere, "Tibetan Tales from the Top of the World" by author and illustrator Naomi C. Rose (and the assistance of Tenzin Palsang, Tibetan translator) is a lovely bilingual collection of children's wisdom tales from Tibetan traditions. It is the second such collection by the author, following the earlier "Tibetan Tales for Little Buddhas," a special collaboration that won both a Nautilus Book award and an International Storytelling World Honor award.

Paging through "Tibetan Tales from the Top of the World" it is easy to see why this author/illustrator deserves such high honors and awards. The three wisdom tales, Prince Jampa's Surprise, Sonam and the Stolen Cow, and Tashi's Gold, are simply told in both English and Tibetan, illustrated with beautiful colorful paintings of Tibetan scenes including special miniatures of Tibetan wildlife, catalogued carefully at the end. This marvelous edition of "Tibetan Tales from the Top of the World" is sure to enchant readers young and old with its exotic details and simple messages of gratitude, honesty, and humility as virtues to be attained. As with other of the author's undertakings, a portion of the proceeds obtained for this publication benefit the Tibetan refugee children.





Children's Literature Comprehensive Database, December 2009


This lively collection with prefatory comments by His Holiness the Dalai Lama and Richard Gere, is the second of its kind from author-illustrator Naomi Rose (Tibetan Tales for Little Buddhas). In bilingual text, translated into Tibetan by Tenzin Palsang, this 64-page collection includes three intriguing stories. “Prince Jampa’s Surprise” is about a prince who acts on his people’s assumptions about their neighboring kingdom, only to be taken aback at the reality he discovers. In “Sonam and the Stolen Cow,” a young nun is accused of stealing a calf. She flees in righteous indignation, until an encounter with an all-knowing monkey gives her perspective. “Tashi’s Gold” is a lesson about greed, involving wonderful dramatic elements such as a singing guardian spirit and atmospheric gusts of wind. A glossary with phonetic pronunciations and an author’s note are located in the front matter. Back matter includes captioned spot illustrations of the Tibetan wildlife featured in the art as part of the setting. Rose’s text is clear, simple, and direct. Briskly paced but lyrical in quality, the stories make their points without didacticism. They reflect the unique blend of thoughtful actions and deeply held values that characterize the Tibetan Buddhist lifeway. A photograph placed in front matter and then again in the middle story complements the colorful paintings. A rare bilingual offering and a wonderful gift to young readers. REVIEWER: Uma Krishnaswami



 

Kirkus Reviews, November 2009

Rose’s follow-up to Tibetan Tales for Little Buddhas (2004) features three more traditional tales. In the first, generations have passed down stories of the savagery of the people of Varasi. Prince Jampa thinks he’s discovered their plot, so he sets out on a preemptive invasion. When he arrives at the palace, Jampa gets a surprise. In the next, Sonam, a reclusive nun, is accused of stealing. She’s innocent, but she learns a lesson about the implications of her past crimes thanks to a helpful monkey. And finally Tashi finds a lake full of gold nuggets. The wise, fearsome guardian goddess lets him take one nugget. Wiley Tashi takes his father back to get his one nugget. The two plan to take the whole family, but instead learn money doesn’t buy happiness and sharing is a reward unto itself. The paintings are bright and their subjects expressive, if a bit stiff. Although the preface and forward from Richard Gere and the Dalai Lama, respectively, have a regrettably throwaway feel, these three moralistic tales presented in both English and Tibetan is a good addition to large folklore collections. 

 
Shambhala Sun, December 2009
Recommended book for the holidays.


Tibetan Tales from the Top of the World features three traditional stories in both English and Tibetan. The Tibetan translation is by Pasang Tenzin; the foreword is by the Dalai Lama; the preface is by Richard Gere; and the text and dreamy illustrations are by Naomi C. Rose, who will be donating some of the sale proceeds to benefit Tibetan refugees.